Profile Review: M/30 years old/Vancouver, WA


Reply
 
Topic Tools Search this Thread
Aaomalley is offline Aaomalley Post #1  January 4,2012, 10:57pm
Aaomalley's Avatar

Newbie

Joined: Jan 2012

Posts: 5

See profile

Q-Other than your parents, who has been the most influential person in your life and why?*
A-My friend Jeremy. We have known each other for 15 years and have gone through everything together throughout our lives. He pushes me intellectually and picks me up emotionally.*

Q-what is the most important quality you are looking for in another person?
A-Curiosity. I feel that constant drive to know more about the world today than I did yesterday, and I greatly appreciate it in other people. I also need someone that communicates well, not just every day things but emotionally and intellectually as well. My wish list isn't that long, I love a girl with nice tattoo's, someone that is musical would be awesome, and someone with a passion for travel (even if income prevents it). everything else simply limits people too much and makes life uninteresting, who wants their idea of perfect anyway, the unknown is better anyway.

Q-Other than your appearance, what is the first thing people notice about you and why?
A-My laugh. It is loud and very distinctive, but not annoying.*

Q-what is one thing that people don't notice about you right away that you wish they would?
A-I am a lot deeper than many of my friends notice, and that is hard sometimes. I am a very emotional person, but really try to operate from a purely rational position which is a bit of an enigma. I guess I want people to know more about me and less about what I enjoy or am passionate about that is external.

Q-what are five things you can't live without?
A-TIVO, Education, Conversation, Physical contact, and Pets

Q-describe the last book you read and enjoyed. What was it about? What did you like most about it?
A-Well, the last full book I read was "Eight Mindful Steps to Happiness" by a Buddhist monk Bhante Guarantana. It explores how the Eight fold path of Buddhism can improve your joy in life. It was half for work and half for myself as I try to lead a mindful life. Right now I am reading "Hitchhikers Guide" which is a whole different type of philosophy altogether.

A-is there any additional information that you would like your matches to know about you?

A-Just that I can come across as aloof or distant when people first meet me, and some people mistake it for being either stuck up or angry, which it isn't. I am a pretty shy person at first but that only lasts until the first good conversation topic.

Q-What are you most passionate about?
A-I am most passionate about learning. I am always trying to learn something interesting everyday. I consider myself a perpetual student and like to read about many different topics. I want to be able to form an educated opinion about as many topics as I can and thirst to learn new things.*

Q-what are three things for which you are the most thankful?
A-The opportunities I have had educationally and professionally,*My closeness with my family. I am lucky to have a very tight knit family,*My friends and everything they do for me on a daily basis.

Q-the four things your friends say about you are?
A-Good listener, Loyal, Intelligence, and Genuine

Q-What are three of my best life skills?
A-Achieving personal goals, Maintaining a network of close friends, Using humor to make friends laugh.

Q-How do you typically spend your leisure time?
A-Because of my current work schedule I don't do anything too exciting. I spend most of my time watching TV, reading and listening to music. Of the three I am most passionate about listening to music. When I get the chance I love going to a Timbers match or hiking if I can find someone to go with me. I also love to travel but generally only get one trip a year out of the country, which I would like to change sometime soon.*

BASICS---
Occupation: Full Time Nursing Student
Height: 5'11"
Education: Bachelors Degree
Religion: Spiritual but not religious

In addition to this I also have 9 photos posted including a close-up face shot, a full body shot, an activity photo, and a group photo. My profile is fully completed with something marked in each of the "Something to Talk sections.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I have been on e-harmony for Over a year and in the beginning got fairly good results but I have had 1 date in the past 6 months from this site despite regularly updating my profile and adding different pictures regularly. I rarely even have matches respond to my first questions, and I always make sure to follow up with a "nudge" if I hear nothing after a week. When I read through the profile it says what I want it to say about me, but my results are clear that there is something in my profile that is off-putting to my matches (I know my photos are good pics of me and generally attractive/fun).

I also wanted feedback about the "do you want children" question. I do not want biological children right now, though I definitely leave the option open to change my mind in the future (which is why I haven't had the vasectomy done). I am also open to the option of adoption in the future, and am much more open to that then biological kids. I don't want to mislead anyone by putti "maybe" as an answer but answering "no" would also not be completely accurate. I also know that saying no would cause many women, especially at my age, to skip over my profile. I ask because I had a date about 2 months ago that ended almost immediately after I mentioned that I am not sold on the idea of biological kids when it came up in conversation.
What would you suggest I put as an answer, and is it appropriate to say a little more within the profile itself?

I really appreciate the feedback, please feel free to be as harsh as you want I have no problem taking constructive brutal criticism well and running with it.

Also is there a place where I can post my photos to have people review them?
 
  Reply With Quote
DancingFool is offline DancingFool Post #2  January 5,2012, 10:33am
DancingFool's Avatar

Power Poster

Joined: Jan 2009

Posts: 5,750

See profile

You are basically excluding all women who don't have tattoos and aren't musical in addition to wanting to travel. You are essentially making your pool small. On top of that, the fact that you are 30 and don't want to have children will make that pool even smaller. So to answer that question, I think you should put down "maybe" and then explain under additional info that you are fine with adoption but don't want your own. Realize that your choice is out of the norm and will be a deal breaker for most women. However, if that's how you feel, then don't lie about it just to get dates.
 
  Reply With Quote
eharmonyjc is online now eharmonyjc Post #3  January 5,2012, 11:18am
eharmonyjc's Avatar

:-D

Veteran

Joined: Nov 2011

Colorado!

Posts: 1,203

See profile

My comments in green, I am target audience (29/f)

Aaomalley wrote :
Q-Other than your parents, who has been the most influential person in your life and why?*
A-My friend Jeremy. We have known each other for 15 years and have gone through everything together throughout our lives. He pushes me intellectually and picks me up emotionally.*

This is OK I guess, sort of bland and vague.

Q-what is the most important quality you are looking for in another person?
A-Curiosity. I feel that constant drive to know more about the world today than I did yesterday, and I greatly appreciate it in other people. I also need someone that communicates well, not just every day things but emotionally and intellectually as well. My wish list isn't that long, I love a girl with nice tattoo's, someone that is musical would be awesome, and someone with a passion for travel (even if income prevents it). everything else simply limits people too much and makes life uninteresting, who wants their idea of perfect anyway, the unknown is better anyway.

I read this and thought, well, this guy wouldn't like me, I don't have any tattoos and even though I like lots of different kinds of music, I don't consider myself "musical". Putting specific things like this will limit your dating pool. Also for some reason the last line comes off as kind of negative to me, and reads badly with "anyway" twice.

Q-Other than your appearance, what is the first thing people notice about you and why?
A-My laugh. It is loud and very distinctive, but not annoying.*

I like this

Q-what is one thing that people don't notice about you right away that you wish they would?
A-I am a lot deeper than many of my friends notice, and that is hard sometimes. I am a very emotional person, but really try to operate from a purely rational position which is a bit of an enigma. I guess I want people to know more about me and less about what I enjoy or am passionate about that is external.

This sounds super "emo" and like you might be brooding/moody. Also, in the end, the "I'm really a sensitive person once you get to know me" bit is what most people put in this section. I actually think it's the lamest question they ask in the profile though since I've never seen anybody have a real great answer to it.

Q-what are five things you can't live without?
A-TIVO, Education, Conversation, Physical contact, and Pets

This is OK but the "physical contact" part might be taken the wrong way by some people. Also what kind of pets?

Q-describe the last book you read and enjoyed. What was it about? What did you like most about it?
A-Well, the last full book I read was "Eight Mindful Steps to Happiness" by a Buddhist monk Bhante Guarantana. It explores how the Eight fold path of Buddhism can improve your joy in life. It was half for work and half for myself as I try to lead a mindful life. Right now I am reading "Hitchhikers Guide" which is a whole different type of philosophy altogether.

This is good.

A-is there any additional information that you would like your matches to know about you?

A-Just that I can come across as aloof or distant when people first meet me, and some people mistake it for being either stuck up or angry, which it isn't. I am a pretty shy person at first but that only lasts until the first good conversation topic.

All this is not good. It makes it sound like it would be hard to have a conversation with you, and it sort of says something similar to the "don't notice about me" section. This section is more to provide more detail to other things you wrote in your profile but didn't have room to elaborate. Like example, you mention you're a nursing student, but then you also mention work. Is your work the nursing student work stuff, or do you have a different job too? Also you can put something humorous or a tidbit about your life here.

Q-What are you most passionate about?
A-I am most passionate about learning. I am always trying to learn something interesting everyday. I consider myself a perpetual student and like to read about many different topics. I want to be able to form an educated opinion about as many topics as I can and thirst to learn new things.*

I think I know what you were trying to say about being a perpetual student (ie you always like to learn new things), but it comes across totally wrong. Saying you're a perpetual student at the age of 30 would be a huge turn-off for me. Makes it sound like you never grew up and are in "college student" mode for forever. We don't want to date a man-child.

Q-what are three things for which you are the most thankful?
A-The opportunities I have had educationally and professionally,*My closeness with my family. I am lucky to have a very tight knit family,*My friends and everything they do for me on a daily basis.

This is fine

Q-the four things your friends say about you are?
A-Good listener, Loyal, Intelligence, and Genuine

Q-What are three of my best life skills?
A-Achieving personal goals, Maintaining a network of close friends, Using humor to make friends laugh.

Q-How do you typically spend your leisure time?
A-Because of my current work schedule I don't do anything too exciting. I spend most of my time watching TV, reading and listening to music. Of the three I am most passionate about listening to music. When I get the chance I love going to a Timbers match or hiking if I can find someone to go with me. I also love to travel but generally only get one trip a year out of the country, which I would like to change sometime soon.*

This section sounds pretty negative and makes you sound very boring. Do you like to go out to eat or go to live shows? Do you have any other hobbies other than sitting around watching TV and listening to music? What kind of music do you like to listen to? Do you go to live shows or just listen at home? Maybe elaborate more on the travel part? Where do you like to go? Gallivant around Europe or soak up the sun in the Caribbean? One trip out of the country per year is a lot for most people so I don't think there's a need to say "which I would like to change sometime soon". Also it makes it sound like you don't have time to date if all you have free time for is watching TV and listening to music.

BASICS---
Occupation: Full Time Nursing Student
Height: 5'11"
Education: Bachelors Degree
Religion: Spiritual but not religious

In addition to this I also have 9 photos posted including a close-up face shot, a full body shot, an activity photo, and a group photo. My profile is fully completed with something marked in each of the "Something to Talk sections.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I have been on e-harmony for Over a year and in the beginning got fairly good results but I have had 1 date in the past 6 months from this site despite regularly updating my profile and adding different pictures regularly. I rarely even have matches respond to my first questions, and I always make sure to follow up with a "nudge" if I hear nothing after a week. When I read through the profile it says what I want it to say about me, but my results are clear that there is something in my profile that is off-putting to my matches (I know my photos are good pics of me and generally attractive/fun).

I also wanted feedback about the "do you want children" question. I do not want biological children right now, though I definitely leave the option open to change my mind in the future (which is why I haven't had the vasectomy done). I am also open to the option of adoption in the future, and am much more open to that then biological kids. I don't want to mislead anyone by putti "maybe" as an answer but answering "no" would also not be completely accurate. I also know that saying no would cause many women, especially at my age, to skip over my profile. I ask because I had a date about 2 months ago that ended almost immediately after I mentioned that I am not sold on the idea of biological kids when it came up in conversation.
What would you suggest I put as an answer, and is it appropriate to say a little more within the profile itself?

I really appreciate the feedback, please feel free to be as harsh as you want I have no problem taking constructive brutal criticism well and running with it.

Also is there a place where I can post my photos to have people review them?
Overall, I got the impression that you are a kind of negative, boring and kind of lazy guy. I'm sure that's not the case at all but that's how it comes across.

On the 'wants kids' part, I am in the same boat as you. Unsure/leaning towards adoption. I would put "maybe" as your answer since you're not dead set on not having your own child, ever.

Also one last thing to keep in mind is, many of the profiles on eH are inactive or non-paying members. So, they will never respond to you. That's the biggest flaw of eH in my opinion.
 
  Reply With Quote
Aaomalley is offline Aaomalley Post #4  January 5,2012, 11:41am
Aaomalley's Avatar

Newbie

Joined: Jan 2012

Posts: 5

See profile

Pacesetter-
Thank you so much for your feedback, it is the precise thing I wanted to hear. Obviously I know what I was trying to get across so whenever I read through my profile it sounded good to me, it is invaluable to have a woman in my target demographic provide insight into how the profile reads from the outside. After reading your replies I can completely see your point and definitely recognize how my answers could come across as not painting me in the best light.

Obviously I have an answer to everything you questioned that would be solved by adding further information, but ultimately it seems to me the best approach is to re-write everything in a way that paints a better picture from the get go.

If you don't mind I would like some follow-up feedback when I am done revising my answers. I think it would be most helpful to have someone who has provided criticism already review the changes so they have more information as to where the profile started.

Anyway, I can't thank you enough for your response, it will be incredibly helpful for me.
 
  Reply With Quote
eharmonyjc is online now eharmonyjc Post #5  January 5,2012, 12:00pm
eharmonyjc's Avatar

:-D

Veteran

Joined: Nov 2011

Colorado!

Posts: 1,203

See profile

No problem. When you post your revised profile, be sure to do it as a new post in this thread, versus editing your first one. Makes it easier to follow and for other folks to help out too
 
  Reply With Quote
Aaomalley is offline Aaomalley Post #6  January 5,2012, 8:41pm
Aaomalley's Avatar

Newbie

Joined: Jan 2012

Posts: 5

See profile

Here is my edited profile. I hope this does a better job of getting ME across rather than the dull and stodgy person that was coming across.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Q-Other than your parents, who has been the most influential person in your life and why?
A-There are so many people who have impacted my life so profoundly it is definitely difficult to choose one. I suppose it would likely be my close friend Jeremy. I have known him since I was 14 and we have gone through everything together and he was always able to help me out of tough situations. More than that though is that he has had a pretty hard life, drugs, family problems, deaths, unplanned baby and so much more. Through everything I have witnessed him face he has come out the other side a better and more complete person. He never ran and hid from any of his life problems, rather choosing to face them head-on and make rational decisions*

Q-What is the most important quality you are looking for in another person?
A-By far the most important thing I need from a romantic partner is the ability to communicate well. Having worked in the mental health field I place a ton of stock in open and honest communication as the silver bullet for almost all difficulties in relationships. I also deeply value the ability to laugh at life in all of it's insanity and ridiculousness. My favorite quote has always been "never take life too seriously, you'll never get out alive". Laughter cures all ills, and I need a partner who can take the darkest of situations and make them light.*

Q-Other than your appearance, what is the frost thing people notice about you?
A-My laugh. People always tell me they love my laugh and can always find me in a crowd by listening for it. It is loud and distinctive, I am constantly told that it sounds exactly like Seth Rogan if that gives you an idea.

Q-What is one thing people don't notice about you right away that you wish they would?
A-I am generally an open book with those in my life, but there are some things I think people may miss. One of them is my traditional beliefs when it comes to family. I strongly believe that family comes first, and that as a son it is my duty to care for my parents as they get older. I don't buy in to all the traditional gender roles and that BS, but I do think that children have obligations to their family first. The other thing people may miss about me is that I am hopelessly romantic. Despite being a bit cynical in general I do want the entire romance story in my life.

Q-What are the 5 things you cannot live without?
A-Education, TIVO, amazing conversation, my puppy-he's my kick ass little guy, books.

Q-Describe the last book you read and enjoyed. What was it about? What did you enjoy about it?
A-Well, the last full book I read completely was "Eight Mindful Steps to Happiness" by a monk named Bhante Guarantana. It explores the noble eight-fold path of Buddhism and how it can improve your life by implanting joy in place of judgment. *It was half for my old job (I just left the job mid-December) and half for personal enjoyment. Right now I am reading "Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy" which has been amazing to this point. It provides a refreshing look at humanity and the universe, it discusses an interesting philosophy of life, the universe and everything. **

Q-Is there any additional information you would like Your matches to know about you?
A-I am just starting a Nursing program. The program takes a huge chunk of time dedicated to it. Because of this I have had to tightly schedule my life which is antithetical to how I normally like things to be. I usually enjoy being spontaneous and randomly deciding to take a trip to Newport or Seattle (once to Chicago at 4am) so the idea of not being able to drop everything and change direction at a drop of a hat. I am dedicated to maintaining a social life and still having a good time, but it just has to be more scheduled. This means that if we get together it may take some extra planning.

Q-What are you passionate about?
A-I am passionate about so much it is hard to sum it up. My first passion has to be learning, there is nothing like the feeling you get when you're learning something new and it clicks and suddenly you know something you didn't 5 minutes before. After that I am really dedicated to helping people, I was a counselor before going back to school and love helping people be better to themselves. Other than that I love travel and force myself to take 1 trip outside the US every year, I love going out and tasting craft cocktails (especially whiskey cocktails) with my good friends, SCUBA when I can, Hiking, playing with my dog, and meditation.

Q-What are the 3 things for which you are most thankful?
A-The opportunities I have educationally and professionally,*My closeness with my family. I am lucky to have a very tight knit family,*My friends and everything they do for me on a daily basis

Q-How do you typically spend your leisure time?
A-I remember leisure time In the rare times when I can get down time I do as much as I possibly can (after catching up on sleep). I love just going out and walking around the niche neighborhoods in Portland, finding cool new shops/restaurants/bars. I love hiking though I haven't done enough of it, as well as camping. I am planning on doing some cooking classes, I love cooking for friends but only have a few things I do really well. I also do a lot of reading in my leisure time, probably what I do most. I tend to read articles and journals more than books because they can be squeezed in a 15 minute spot of down time.*
Last edited by Aaomalley; January 14,2012 at 8:34pm.
 
  Reply With Quote
Reply


Topic Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new topics
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are Off

Similar Topics
Topic Topic Starter Board Replies Last Post
Profile review -- 28/F Bethiegirl Using eHarmony 10 December 27,2011 6:33pm
A Profile Review v2, Please (Male, 43) namati Using eHarmony 15 January 1,2011 7:46pm
Please review my profile. { 28 / female } girlygeek82 Using eHarmony 17 December 12,2010 2:20pm
Please review my profile. Male, 43. namati Using eHarmony 11 December 9,2010 2:37am

Looking for a Great Relationship?

Get started now. Fill out this form and take the questionnaire to receive your matches.

First Name:

I'm a:
seeking

Postal Code:

Country:

Email:

Confirm Email:

Password:


How did you hear about us?


Latest on our Dating Advice Discussion Boards

“Thanks! dmi said it best when he said the variation between races are too wide to exclude any race.” –  sun73

Join the “How much does race play in your dating someone?” discussion

“ If you know, then, that you've already friend-zoned him, I don't see much point in meeting. I misread your op and thought you were just trying to decide how you felt about him. If you know you ... ” –  singinggirl

Join the “Yellow flags...To Proceed or not to proceed, that is the question?” discussion

“ We also have the same friends. Yesterday there was an outing and I decided to go regardless if he was going to be there or not. Every time he saw me he went somewhere else. One of his friends ... ” –  lynntlb78

Join the “Can I wait and move on at the same time?” discussion

“You will have the option to close a match at any time, but if it is ONLY giving you the option to close, that means the other person has already closed it.” –  eH_Advice_Host_Eve

Join the “Question, archive, close...” discussion

“ Very true, this is a high percentage of the members who use free comm weekends.” –  eH_Advice_Host_Eve

Join the “dreaded free weekend” discussion



All times are GMT -8. The time now is 4:27pm.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2012, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.0