Profile critique please, 45 yo female newbie


Reply
  • Page 1 of 2
  • 1
  • 2
 
Topic Tools Search this Thread
mdepsmom is offline mdepsmom Post #1  June 15,2011, 8:10pm
mdepsmom's Avatar

Newbie

Joined: Jun 2011

Posts: 18

See profile

Hi everyone, I'm very new (almost 3 weeks) to eharmony and very new (almost 3 weeks! how about that!) to online dating, having been divorced for almost two years now. This is my first time getting "back out there." I have an 8 year old son.

I've tweaked my profile quite a bit and I am pretty happy with it but I would love some constructive criticism/suggestions from those of you who can be far more objective than I am.

Thank you in advance for your help.

So here goes:

Most passionate about:
My son -- he is so smart and bright and funny, and he makes every day better. Hearing about his day, and telling him goodnight and that I love him, even on the days when he is not with me -- those are the things that really matter to me.

Most important thing I'm looking for:
The most important quality I'm looking for is the ability to communicate. Being able to keep those lines of communication open and talking things through -- that's key for me. Also just as important to me is to find someone who is 100% committed to the relationship.

Most influential person:
My son has been the most influential person in my life. He has taught me the ability to love unconditionally and to be loved in that way in return, to take pleasure in simple things, to be less selfish, and to have more patience.

Most thankful for:
My son
My friends
My health

Best life skills:
Using humor to make friends laugh
Raising and/or caring for children
Being a good friend & companion


The one thing I wish more people would notice about me:
I have no rhythm -- seriously, I can't dance, and believe me I've tried. There! Now it's out there!

I can't live without:
  • My son
  • A good steak -- bone-in ribeye, medium rare
  • The Sunday paper
  • My DVR
  • Coffee
First thing people notice about me:
My sense of humor. I can be quiet around new people and making other people laugh makes me feel more comfortable and at ease.

Additional info I want you to know:
I have so much to offer as a partner. I am loving, supportive, fun, loyal, smart, energetic, confident, and romantic. I'm in a really good place in my life, I have a great job and great friends, a beautiful home, and of course a wonderful son. But I am really missing an intimate, loving relationship and the companionship that comes along with it.

Typically spend my leisure time:
First and foremost, I'm a mom and most enjoy spending time w/ my son. When I am on my own, I enjoy reading, catching up on tv and movies, going to sporting events and concerts, art festivals, travel, doing projects around the house, spending time with my friends, and I keep fit by swimming and walking my puppy. I also love to cook and am the consummate food snob. I love to entertain and plan everything from big Thanksgiving dinners to small intimate meals for two. Would love to find someone to share my love of cooking; or I am more than happy to do all the cooking if you do the dishes!

Last book read/enjoyed:
Medium Raw, by Anthony Bourdain -- it's about his life in restaurant kitchens and how that transferred into his popular No Reservations show on the Travel Channel. I love his books and his show; he can be raunchy but it is such a good read. I am currently reading the memoir Eating My Words by Mimi Sheraton -- she is the former NY Times restaurant critic. It's a fascinating behind-the-scenes look at her experiences dining in some of the most famous restaurants in the world, and how having what I'd consider to be a dream job is not all that.

My friends describe me as:
Warm
Funny
Caring
Intelligent
 
  Reply With Quote
tangochef is offline tangochef Post #2  June 15,2011, 8:47pm
tangochef's Avatar

enjoying NYC.

Veteran

Joined: May 2011

Southern CA

Posts: 2,361

See profile

I am sure that others will mention that your profile is overwhelmed by you being a mother to your son. It is mentioned in almost every section.

You do have a good interests section though.

BTW, have you read "Kitchen Confidential"? It is a good read as well.
 
  Reply With Quote
KikiAZ is offline KikiAZ Post #3  June 16,2011, 9:15am
KikiAZ's Avatar

posting from the 6th largest city in America

Veteran

Joined: Apr 2011

Posts: 1,649

See profile

mdepsmom wrote :
Hi everyone, I'm very new (almost 3 weeks) to eharmony and very new (almost 3 weeks! how about that!) to online dating, having been divorced for almost two years now. This is my first time getting "back out there." I have an 8 year old son.

I've tweaked my profile quite a bit and I am pretty happy with it but I would love some constructive criticism/suggestions from those of you who can be far more objective than I am.

Thank you in advance for your help.

So here goes:

Most passionate about:
My son -- he is so smart and bright and funny, and he makes every day better. Hearing about his day, and telling him goodnight and that I love him, even on the days when he is not with me -- those are the things that really matter to me.

Most important thing I'm looking for:
The most important quality I'm looking for is the ability to communicate. Being able to keep those lines of communication open and talking things through -- that's key for me. Also just as important to me is to find someone who is 100% committed to the relationship.

Most influential person:
My son has been the most influential person in my life. He has taught me the ability to love unconditionally and to be loved in that way in return, to take pleasure in simple things, to be less selfish, and to have more patience.

Most thankful for:
My son
My friends
My health

Best life skills:
Using humor to make friends laugh
Raising and/or caring for children
Being a good friend & companion


The one thing I wish more people would notice about me:
I have no rhythm -- seriously, I can't dance, and believe me I've tried. There! Now it's out there!


I can't live without:
  • My son
  • A good steak -- bone-in ribeye, medium rare
  • The Sunday paper
  • My DVR (TO WATCH???? Give some specifics)
  • Coffee
First thing people notice about me:
My sense of humor. I can be quiet around new people and making other people laugh makes me feel more comfortable and at ease.

Additional info I want you to know:
I have so much to offer as a partner. I am loving, supportive, fun, loyal, smart, energetic, confident, and romantic. I'm in a really good place in my life, I have a great job and great friends, a beautiful home, and of course a wonderful son. But I am really missing an intimate, loving relationship and the companionship that comes along with it.

Typically spend my leisure time:
First and foremost, I'm a mom and most enjoy spending time w/ my son. When I am on my own, I enjoy reading, catching up on tv and movies, going to sporting events and concerts, art festivals, travel, doing projects around the house, spending time with my friends, and I keep fit by swimming and walking my puppy. I also love to cook and am the consummate food snob. I love to entertain and plan everything from big Thanksgiving dinners to small intimate meals for two. Would love to find someone to share my love of cooking; or I am more than happy to do all the cooking if you do the dishes!

Last book read/enjoyed:
Medium Raw, by Anthony Bourdain -- it's about his life in restaurant kitchens and how that transferred into his popular No Reservations show on the Travel Channel. I love his books and his show; he can be raunchy but it is such a good read. I am currently reading the memoir Eating My Words by Mimi Sheraton -- she is the former NY Times restaurant critic. It's a fascinating behind-the-scenes look at her experiences dining in some of the most famous restaurants in the world, and how having what I'd consider to be a dream job is not all that.

My friends describe me as:
Warm
Funny
Caring
Intelligent

I am a divorced mom of an 8 year old too. You have some nice stuff here. BUT you need to tone down the mom stuff. A man is not looking for a mom. He might like that you are a loving mom but he doesn't pick women based on that. (Just as you aren't picking guys based on only the info that they have a kid they love, right???)

He wants a vibrant, smart, financially & emotionally stable, confident, preferably HOT woman. I don't see any pics but you sound good on the other stuff.

My advice is two-fold...add a few more specifics and keep your reference to your son to ONE. One where you mention/hint at his age. A guy with kids will want to know if you are in the same place (eg soccer/Wiggles/prom) as he is.

Every reference to your son is a failure to show some new aspect/make some new connection with a man.

Add more about the foods you cook/love....are you a bbq queen? a baking goddess? do you love all things Asian? Give some hooks for him to say either "me too!" or "tell me about that."

Maybe something about your puppy (not all guys are into that, but if you are..."my 9 month old Lab Benji...I almost have him trained not to eat my heels") or the swimming.....where at Lincoln park pool, or do you do laps every morning or what???

You are off to a good start....post it again after your changes. Best. K
 
  Reply With Quote
DancingFool is offline DancingFool Post #4  June 16,2011, 9:37am
DancingFool's Avatar

Power Poster

Joined: Jan 2009

Posts: 5,750

See profile

You mention your son so much that you come across as obsessed to the point of unhealthy. The only mention of your son in your profile should be that you have one and how old he is. That is all. It seems like you have lost yourself and who you are as an adult person in your marriage, motherhood and divorce. (This may be incorrect, but it's how it reads from your profile) Remember that being a mother is just one part of who you are but it's not all there is to you.

Your profile needs to focus on you as an adult woman, a human being with passions and interests and hobbies and jobs and activities and so on. Who are you as a person, as a woman outside of being a mother?
 
  Reply With Quote
mdepsmom is offline mdepsmom Post #5  June 16,2011, 11:03am
mdepsmom's Avatar

Newbie

Joined: Jun 2011

Posts: 18

See profile

Thanks for the feedback so far, it has been extremely helpful. I'm not obsessed w/ my son by any means -- I so look forward to my "me" time when he is w/ his dad -- but being a mom (and a single parent) is such a huge part of who I am that I forget sometimes there are other sides to me. I will definitely re-work some areas and will re-post later tonight.
 
  Reply With Quote
mdepsmom is offline mdepsmom Post #6  June 16,2011, 2:16pm
mdepsmom's Avatar

Newbie

Joined: Jun 2011

Posts: 18

See profile

Ok, I'm back, and have made some changes. Please let me know what you think.

Most passionate about:
I am most passionate about being the best mom I can be to my 8-year old son.

Most influential person:
The most influential person in my life was a former boss who, through example, taught me to always treat people with kindness and respect if you expect the same from them in return. I try to live my life that way every day, even when the kindness and respect are not always reciprocal.

Most thankful for:
My family and friends
My health
My career

Can’t live without:
A good steak (bone-in ribeye, medium rare)
The Sunday paper
Coffee
The sight of my puppy’s happy face when I get home
My DVR, when I can’t catch my favorite shows

Typically spend my time:
Enjoy reading, catching up on tv/movies, sporting events (go Wings!), concerts, art festivals, travel (love cruises), dining out (sushi, Lolo’s, Five Guys) & spending time w/friends. Keep fit doing laps in my pool & daily walks w/my dog (have an 11-month old Cavachon, my first dog ever! Maybe one day I’ll trust him to go outside by himself & not destroy my yard). Also love to cook (specialties include double chocolate cheesecake, almond roca, mac&cheese) & am a total food snob. Love to entertain & plan everything from Thanksgiving to intimate meals for 2. Would love to find someone to share my love of cooking, or I’ll do the cooking if you do the dishes!

Additional info I want you to know:
I have so much to offer as a partner. I am loving, supportive, fun (and funny -- my friends say I’m a hoot), loyal, smart, confident, and romantic. I’m in a really good place in my life, I have a great job, great friends, a beautiful home, and a wonderful kid. But I am really missing an intimate, loving relationship and the companionship that comes along with it.
 
  Reply With Quote
tangochef is offline tangochef Post #7  June 16,2011, 2:44pm
tangochef's Avatar

enjoying NYC.

Veteran

Joined: May 2011

Southern CA

Posts: 2,361

See profile

mdepsmom wrote :
Thanks for the feedback so far, it has been extremely helpful. I'm not obsessed w/ my son by any means -- ...
I saw the irony of the comment above when I noticed your user name.

I liked the re-write by the way.
 
  Reply With Quote
ami1uwant is offline ami1uwant Post #8  June 16,2011, 3:19pm
ami1uwant's Avatar

Virtuoso

Joined: Feb 2008

Seattle, WA

Posts: 4,640

See profile

From a guys perspective in your target age range....


I agreed with the others ...you need to tone down your son...but not eliminate him. Under the 5 things you cant live without you can pout your son...and then in one of the passages you can tell a story related to your son.

Under the passionate part....you should talk about why you chose your career, or there is a cause or hobby/interest you will never fgive up, or you colunteer always for certain causes.


I dont know what career you do.....

What interests do you have that is outside of your son other than 99% of us...hanging out with friends etc.

What about your pics and your age range and distance range ???
 
  Reply With Quote
HelenDanger is offline HelenDanger Post #9  June 16,2011, 4:38pm
HelenDanger's Avatar

happy to be back!

Veteran

Joined: Jun 2011

The South, for the moment.

Posts: 1,164

See profile

mdepsmom wrote :
Ok, I'm back, and have made some changes. Please let me know what you think.

Most passionate about:
I'd put other stuff here. Just things you love to do and causes you care about. Maybe put something about your spirituality or your outlook on life in general. And then say you're passionate about taking care of your family. Now I know you're normal! But "passion" and "son" sound a little funny together even though I know what you meant by it. And dating is about your non-maternal side. Your inner wild woman, if you see what I mean. Details about your son can come later. In a conversation.
I am most passionate about being the best mom I can be to my 8-year old son.

Most influential person:
If you want to be consistent about the love of family theme, I'd put an older family member in here too.
The most influential person in my life was a former boss who, through example, taught me to always treat people with kindness and respect if you expect the same from them in return. I try to live my life that way every day, even when the kindness and respect are not always reciprocal.

Most thankful for:
My family and friends
My health
My career
I'd end the list with something silly and unexpected. To spark conversation. But that's just me. This is great.

Can’t live without:
Love this part. Love love love it!! Is there a way to lead with it? It shows real life details about you that make you interesting.
A good steak (bone-in ribeye, medium rare)
The Sunday paper
Coffee
The sight of my puppy’s happy face when I get home
My DVR, when I can’t catch my favorite shows

Typically spend my time:
Excellent!
Enjoy reading, catching up on tv/movies, sporting events (go Wings!), concerts, art festivals, travel (love cruises), dining out (sushi, Lolo’s, Five Guys) & spending time w/friends. Keep fit doing laps in my pool & daily walks w/my dog (have an 11-month old Cavachon, my first dog ever! Maybe one day I’ll trust him to go outside by himself & not destroy my yard). Also love to cook (specialties include double chocolate cheesecake, almond roca, mac&cheese) & am a total food snob. Love to entertain & plan everything from Thanksgiving to intimate meals for 2. Would love to find someone to share my love of cooking, or I’ll do the cooking if you do the dishes!

Additional info I want you to know:
Beautiful!
I have so much to offer as a partner. I am loving, supportive, fun (and funny -- my friends say I’m a hoot), loyal, smart, confident, and romantic. I’m in a really good place in my life, I have a great job, great friends, a beautiful home, and a wonderful kid. But I am really missing an intimate, loving relationship and the companionship that comes along with it.
My ideas are in red. Great profile!
 
  Reply With Quote
D_Lion is online now D_Lion Post #10  June 16,2011, 6:27pm
D_Lion's Avatar

- Ladies want to wring my neck - you have been warned!

Sage

Joined: Aug 2008

Posts: 31,699

See profile

My reactions are in blue text. Red highlight I applied to your text is something which makes me especially likely to close; green highlight is something which makes me especially inclined to write.

Keep in mind that a large percentage of matches are abandoned profiles, or non-paying members, and will not write or reply for that reason.

Matches who view and don't write, or close you, are the ones to be more concerned over - especially those who were active during a free weekend.


mdepsmom wrote :
Most passionate about:
My son -- he is so smart and bright and funny, and he makes every day better. Hearing about his day, and telling him goodnight and that I love him, even on the days when he is not with me -- those are the things that really matter to me.


I close for having children, but I would close for this answer even if I was okay with children.

This answer does not distinguish you in any way from all the other millions of people with children!

This is your profile on a dating site - and the content needs to make you an appealing, sexy, fun, healthy person.


Most important thing I'm looking for:
The most important quality I'm looking for is the ability to communicate. Being able to keep those lines of communication open and talking things through -- that's key for me. Also just as important to me is to find someone who is 100% committed to the relationship.


Don't bother to restate the question.

I would get rid of the "100% committed" part - that's just baggage. Better would be to use the parts further down in your profile to describe yourself, in ways you think such men would be drawn toward.


Most influential person:
My son has been the most influential person in my life. He has taught me the ability to love unconditionally and to be loved in that way in return, to take pleasure in simple things, to be less selfish, and to have more patience.


I personally prefer an answer which indicates a more motivational or aspirational person - so an occupational or educational answer is best.

This is a bad answer, in that each of these phrases implies your default behavior is quite unattractive (i.e., selfish, impatient, etc); I'd rewrite this completely to get rid of that implication.

Perhaps it would work to state more directly the things you enjoy now which you became involved in due to having a child?

For instance, instead of writing "take pleasure in simple things," which suggests you were materialistic previously, consider something like "I rediscovered the pleasure of watching children play baseball."

This seems less risky to me - and has the added advantage of giving a match who likes baseball, or sport, or fitness, an extra motivation to communicate.


Most thankful for:
My son
My friends
My health


Too repetitive and generic.

If you answer doesn't show you as a unique individual, it's a bad answer.


Best life skills:
Using humor to make friends laugh
Raising and/or caring for children
Being a good friend & companion


If you want to claim humor, make your matches laugh. If you can't, don't claim it at all.


The one thing I wish more people would notice about me:
I have no rhythm -- seriously, I can't dance, and believe me I've tried. There! Now it's out there!


Jeez! This isn't even an answer.

Creativity isn't easy, I know, but this needs some inspiration to come with a better answer.



I can't live without:
  • My son
  • A good steak -- bone-in ribeye, medium rare
  • The Sunday paper
  • My DVR
  • Coffee
First thing people notice about me:
My sense of humor. I can be quiet around new people and making other people laugh makes me feel more comfortable and at ease.

Additional info I want you to know:
I have so much to offer as a partner. I am loving, supportive, fun, loyal, smart, energetic, confident, and romantic. I'm in a really good place in my life, I have a great job and great friends, a beautiful home, and of course a wonderful son. But I am really missing an intimate, loving relationship and the companionship that comes along with it.


This answer sounds overweight. I would definitely fix that.


Typically spend my leisure time:
First and foremost, I'm a mom and most enjoy spending time w/ my son. When I am on my own, I enjoy reading, catching up on tv and movies, going to sporting events and concerts, art festivals, travel, doing projects around the house, spending time with my friends, and I keep fit by swimming and walking my puppy. I also love to cook and am the consummate food snob. I love to entertain and plan everything from big Thanksgiving dinners to small intimate meals for two. Would love to find someone to share my love of cooking; or I am more than happy to do all the cooking if you do the dishes!

Last book read/enjoyed:
Medium Raw, by Anthony Bourdain -- it's about his life in restaurant kitchens and how that transferred into his popular No Reservations show on the Travel Channel. I love his books and his show; he can be raunchy but it is such a good read. I am currently reading the memoir Eating My Words by Mimi Sheraton -- she is the former NY Times restaurant critic. It's a fascinating behind-the-scenes look at her experiences dining in some of the most famous restaurants in the world, and how having what I'd consider to be a dream job is not all that.


An appealing, unusual answer.


My friends describe me as:
Warm
Funny
Caring
Intelligent

I think you should consider that my view is of a person who doesn't write matches with children, but I consider the child-centric references far too many, and too overpowering.

It's simply not necessary to state that you care about your child - that may be assumed.

Aside from that, you have some baggage problems (which is subtle) and bad content.

Overall, this seems competent - a bit above the average quality of those I receive.

It got more appealing to the end, for me.

I think you write well enough that you can make a large improvement, though.
 
  Reply With Quote
Reply
  • Page 1 of 2
  • 1
  • 2


Topic Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new topics
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are Off

Similar Topics
Topic Topic Starter Board Replies Last Post
profile review 37 yr old female mstewar1 Using eHarmony 5 May 16,2011 8:22pm
Profile Review Requested: 29 yo female dezi2468 Using eHarmony 6 February 27,2011 5:16pm
Profile Review Request: 29 yo Female dezi2468 Using eHarmony 6 February 25,2011 9:38pm
Please review my profile. { 28 / female } girlygeek82 Using eHarmony 17 December 12,2010 2:20pm

Looking for a Great Relationship?

Get started now. Fill out this form and take the questionnaire to receive your matches.

First Name:

I'm a:
seeking

Postal Code:

Country:

Email:

Confirm Email:

Password:


How did you hear about us?


Latest on our Dating Advice Discussion Boards

“Exit interviews are highly recommended in many dating books and in other life strategy books. They are very effective. I think he would answer honestly to the some point. I know that is horrible and ... ” –  biking_girl

Join the “Exit interview after unsuccessful date” discussion

“And I'd also add that while a successful stable job down the road and a solid income is helpful in attracting a woman, it's no guarantee that finding love will be easy for you. I know plenty of men ... ” –  boschimsp

Join the “Should I ever date in college?” discussion

“I think if someone says they can't meet you for weeks, they are lukewarm interested. Even if he were truly busy with a project, he'd be able to drop you an email or a text here and there. I took ... ” –  Carole1520

Join the “Did he poof?” discussion

“ Yes, illegal aliens aren't treated as illegals. lol OP, trust your gut. A few months ago, I met a guy on match, who said his membership was expiring, and gave me his IM so we could chat. I ... ” –  Carole1520

Join the “Match from another country...is he a "fraud"?” discussion

“I thought this thread was about exercise. Positive OP though...nice to see.” –  Breezy1

Join the “It's a matter of fit” discussion



All times are GMT -8. The time now is 7:52pm.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2012, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.0