beachyplum is offline beachyplum Post #1  October 12,2008, 1:20pm
beachyplum's Avatar

is happy.

Quick Study

Joined: Oct 2008

Massachusetts

Posts: 151

See profile



I've been observing the boards for a little bit - and finally decided to take the plunge and post a topic.


I've been on EHarmony for a while - though sort of off and on. I'll keep up with it for a little while, then neglect it and there are so many matches that it becomes a chore to sort through them all.


I have noticed that I have a few things that I will usually close out for, and I'm curious what other's will instantly close out for. I know I'm opening myself up for criticism, but that's okay, bring it on if you must, I can handle it!


My list:


1. Someone who is shorter than I am. I'm 5'6" - and it's nothing against short dudes, but I have a "thing" about feeling large. (no, I'm not large - I'm a size 2/4) I actually love to wear heels too - so someone short poses a problem for me. I usually date very tall men - however - I did recently step out of the box on that criteria and met someone who, if anything, will be a lifelong friend. The amount of things we have in common on a whole 'nother level is uncanny! (I wear my flat shoes around him as much as possible, though he really really likes me in heels! LOL)


2. I scroll down to books read - and if they don't read - I will usually close them out. You could list academic text books or technical manuals if you're a mechanic, I don't care, but everyone should read something!


3. Someone who says they're into "Star Trek" or "Dungeons & Dragons" Sorry guys, when I was in school, these interests seemed to have quite the little obsessive followers - almost cult-like, total turn off.


4. If your under job you put "having fun" or "truck driver" - vain, maybe, but you should be employed, and I haven't met any truck drivers that I have anything in common with at all.


5. If under "what your best friend/s know" you put "not now" or something equally stupid, I feel like you're not witty or open enough for my taste - personal preference..nothing more, nothing less.


6.Multiple spelling/grammar errors - I need intellectually intelligent people. I also think that something as important as your first impression should be proofread!


7. If all their answers are pat. We all love our parents and our children and it's a given (in my opinion) that those people are priorities in our lives. I like to hear something else that interests a man other than the obvious in a profile. The obvious doesn't really make you stand out at all and it kind of shows he put little thought into what he wrote. Again, only my opinion!


8.Someone who's into NASCAR - can't stomach the sport! If it's that important to them that they feel the need to mention it in a profile, it's a big enough part of their life and my interests don't include racing every Sunday for what is it - 10 months out of the year? Yikes!


9. No photo. In this day and age, EVERYONE has a digital photo somewhere. They are easy enough to obtain if you don't. I feel like it's lazy and/or dishonest to not represent your whole self, which includes what you look like.


I'm sure I'll add in some more..but these are off the top of my head...have fun!


Amy
 
  Reply With Quote
graceventually is offline graceventually Post #2  October 12,2008, 2:13pm
graceventuall…'s Avatar

was married Nov.28, and is no longer active on this site.

Virtuoso

Joined: May 2008

Posts: 3,056

See profile



OK, here's my automatic close list:


1.) No photo - I agree with the OP, it just seems lazy, if you're seriously trying to meet someone.


2.) More than 3 mentions of any one thing: God, working out, or his finances are the usual culprits. (yes, I said "God". Yes, I'm a pastor, looking for a Christian partner. But eH frequently matches me with guys who sound downright fanatical.)


3.) Stuff about the ex: either negative, i.e. "I want someone who isn't like the witch who dumped me" or overly positive, "I've lost the shining light of my life and am looking for her pale replacement....".
 
  Reply With Quote
tweible is offline tweible Post #3  October 12,2008, 3:27pm
tweible's Avatar

Newbie

Joined: Oct 2008

Phoenix

Posts: 6

See profile



I instantly close out for:

Mentions of Ex's.
Excessive mention of religion (I'd like to date you, not your church)
If any profile pictures contain alochol.
If any of their pictures have them clinging on guys.


and finally...

If thier profile mentions anything about psychology careers or psychology degrees...
 
  Reply With Quote
beachyplum is offline beachyplum Post #4  October 12,2008, 3:43pm
beachyplum's Avatar

is happy.

Quick Study

Joined: Oct 2008

Massachusetts

Posts: 151

See profile

beachyplum, wrote :

I've been observing the boards for a little bit - and finally decided to take the plunge and post a topic.


I've been on EHarmony for a while - though sort of off and on. I'll keep up with it for a little while, then neglect it and there are so many matches that it becomes a chore to sort through them all.


I have noticed that I have a few things that I will usually close out for, and I'm curious what other's will instantly close out for. I know I'm opening myself up for criticism, but that's okay, bring it on if you must, I can handle it!


My list:


1. Someone who is shorter than I am. I'm 5'6" - and it's nothing against short dudes, but I have a "thing" about feeling large. (no, I'm not large - I'm a size 2/4) I actually love to wear heels too - so someone short poses a problem for me. I usually date very tall men - however - I did recently step out of the box on that criteria and met someone who, if anything, will be a lifelong friend. The amount of things we have in common on a whole 'nother level is uncanny! (I wear my flat shoes around him as much as possible, though he really really likes me in heels! LOL)


2. I scroll down to books read - and if they don't read - I will usually close them out. You could list academic text books or technical manuals if you're a mechanic, I don't care, but everyone should read something!


3. Someone who says they're into "Star Trek" or "Dungeons & Dragons" Sorry guys, when I was in school, these interests seemed to have quite the little obsessive followers - almost cult-like, total turn off.


4. If your under job you put "having fun" or "truck driver" - vain, maybe, but you should be employed, and I haven't met any truck drivers that I have anything in common with at all.


5. If under "what your best friend/s know" you put "not now" or something equally stupid, I feel like you're not witty or open enough for my taste - personal preference..nothing more, nothing less.


6.Multiple spelling/grammar errors - I need intellectually intelligent people. I also think that something as important as your first impression should be proofread!


7. If all their answers are pat. We all love our parents and our children and it's a given (in my opinion) that those people are priorities in our lives. I like to hear something else that interests a man other than the obvious in a profile. The obvious doesn't really make you stand out at all and it kind of shows he put little thought into what he wrote. Again, only my opinion!


8.Someone who's into NASCAR - can't stomach the sport! If it's that important to them that they feel the need to mention it in a profile, it's a big enough part of their life and my interests don't include racing every Sunday for what is it - 10 months out of the year? Yikes!


9. No photo. In this day and age, EVERYONE has a digital photo somewhere. They are easy enough to obtain if you don't. I feel like it's lazy and/or dishonest to not represent your whole self, which includes what you look like.


I'm sure I'll add in some more..but these are off the top of my head...have fun!


Amy
I totally forgot, my all time favorite reason to close!


Re: photos -


In the mirror - shirtless - holding up a camera - eyes looking creepily off to the side as they try to take the perfect picture! Makes me giggle just picturing it!


Also, pics that have girls cropped out of them with remnants of her - like an arm or a wisp of hair and a few inches of neckline..,..LOL
 
  Reply With Quote
marylovesplaya is offline marylovesplaya Post #5  October 12,2008, 4:06pm
marylovesplay…'s Avatar

is thinking too much!!!

Pacesetter

Joined: Oct 2008

Norwood, MA

Posts: 371

See profile

I close anyone that mentions NASCAR. It's not my thing, and I find that anyone that I've known that's into that is a little over the top with it. I also close out anyone that I think is pretentious, photos with expensive sports cars, shirtless, things like that. That's not what does it for me. Really poor profiles with zero imagination or terrible grasp of language/punctuation. Typos don't bother me so much, but there's an obvious difference. I won't close right away for no photos but if they don't post them at some point I will.
 
  Reply With Quote
Alena is offline Alena Post #6  October 12,2008, 4:13pm
Alena's Avatar

can't wait 'til summer again

Quick Study

Joined: Jun 2008

Posts: 64

See profile

beachyplum, wrote :

there are so many matches that it becomes a chore to sort through them all.


I have noticed that I have a few things that I will usually close out for, and I'm curious what other's will instantly close out for. I know I'm opening myself up for criticism
sure there's a small chance you might close out someone who just might be the one, but if you've got so many matches that it becomes a chore, you won't be in a good mood while you're communicating or dating them.


closing them outmay actually bedoing them a favor so you're not stringing them along with false hope.


lol at the shirtless picts in the mirror. i guess guys really are visual creatures. they think because they get all dumbstruck be seeing skin that a girl is going to go ga ga over a shirless pict even when he's out of shape eeeewwwwww
 
  Reply With Quote
Songryder is offline Songryder Post #7  October 12,2008, 4:13pm
Songryder's Avatar

A smile is worth singing for!

Virtuoso

Joined: Jun 2008

California

Posts: 2,501

See profile

beachyplum, wrote :

I've been observing the boards for a little bit - and finally decided to take the plunge and post a topic.


I've been on EHarmony for a while - though sort of off and on. I'll keep up with it for a little while, then neglect it and there are so many matches that it becomes a chore to sort through them all.


I have noticed that I have a few things that I will usually close out for, and I'm curious what other's will instantly close out for. I know I'm opening myself up for criticism, but that's okay, bring it on if you must, I can handle it!


My list:


1. Someone who is shorter than I am. I'm 5'6" - and it's nothing against short dudes, but I have a "thing" about feeling large. (no, I'm not large - I'm a size 2/4) I actually love to wear heels too - so someone short poses a problem for me. I usually date very tall men - however - I did recently step out of the box on that criteria and met someone who, if anything, will be a lifelong friend. The amount of things we have in common on a whole 'nother level is uncanny! (I wear my flat shoes around him as much as possible, though he really really likes me in heels! LOL)


2. I scroll down to books read - and if they don't read - I will usually close them out. You could list academic text books or technical manuals if you're a mechanic, I don't care, but everyone should read something!


3. Someone who says they're into "Star Trek" or "Dungeons & Dragons" Sorry guys, when I was in school, these interests seemed to have quite the little obsessive followers - almost cult-like, total turn off.


4. If your under job you put "having fun" or "truck driver" - vain, maybe, but you should be employed, and I haven't met any truck drivers that I have anything in common with at all.


5. If under "what your best friend/s know" you put "not now" or something equally stupid, I feel like you're not witty or open enough for my taste - personal preference..nothing more, nothing less.


6.Multiple spelling/grammar errors - I need intellectually intelligent people. I also think that something as important as your first impression should be proofread!


7. If all their answers are pat. We all love our parents and our children and it's a given (in my opinion) that those people are priorities in our lives. I like to hear something else that interests a man other than the obvious in a profile. The obvious doesn't really make you stand out at all and it kind of shows he put little thought into what he wrote. Again, only my opinion!


8.Someone who's into NASCAR - can't stomach the sport! If it's that important to them that they feel the need to mention it in a profile, it's a big enough part of their life and my interests don't include racing every Sunday for what is it - 10 months out of the year? Yikes!


9. No photo. In this day and age, EVERYONE has a digital photo somewhere. They are easy enough to obtain if you don't. I feel like it's lazy and/or dishonest to not represent your whole self, which includes what you look like.


I'm sure I'll add in some more..but these are off the top of my head...have fun!


Amy
I just did a post on what irks me about people who reiterate being physically fit in every section of their profile, so that's a close button right there.
 
  Reply With Quote
OBeth is offline OBeth Post #8  October 12,2008, 4:26pm
OBeth's Avatar

Quick Study

Joined: Oct 2008

Florida

Posts: 183

See profile



HAVE YOU NOTICED under topic "Success Stories" there are only 20 posts with 491 views vs.. topic "Dating" which has 2908 topics and 109029 views? Pretty clear indication that most and I mean the vast majority of us are going to get nothing out of EH except puzzlement, frustration and dissappointment.


Men and women - we have analyzed, categorized and stereotyped ourselves to death.


I don't think there is a snowballs chance in hell I'm going to meet any man - not even one that is shorter than me, doesn't know how to read (or even spell the name of his "profession").is fat and bald, earns below the poverty line,snorts, farts, has bad table manners, drives a Monster truckthat he modified himself 20 years ago and still thinks that he's God's gift to women and that I owe him something after finally making a dinner date at McDonald'sand paying for my own Big Macto find out that he's absolutely nothing like the photo nor profile that he has put out their to lure me in.


Jaded? You bet. Disgusted? Absolutely. Ashamed of my attitude? Not tonight......
 
  Reply With Quote
HarleyGrrl is offline HarleyGrrl Post #9  October 12,2008, 4:27pm
HarleyGrrl's Avatar

A day without sunshine is like...well, night.

Quick Study

Joined: Aug 2008

Texas

Posts: 144

See profile





2.) More than 3 mentions of any one thing: God, working out, or his finances are the usual culprits. (yes, I said "God". Yes, I'm a pastor, looking for a Christian partner. But eH frequently matches me with guys who sound downright fanatical.)


Halleluia!!





I am so glad I'm not the only one. Sure, I go to church, and I hope to find a partner that would go with me, but come on!





So with that...my automatic close is on the "who is your biggest influence" question. When they mention God, Jesus Christ, Jehovah, or anything close to that...I'm not reading any further. Especially when every third word is ridiculously misspelled.





I feel bad sometimes about doing that, but it just doesn't sound real. It sounds like he's saying what he THINKS a woman wants to hear. So, when God is mentioned in every single answer, and yes...I've gotten that, they're gone.





Between my job,my family and my friends, I meet a lot of people. And I have to say, I have never, EVER come across anyone as holy, as godly, or as devoted to their church, as the men I get on eH. Do they not get out in public or what? How come when I meet a man at a party, or out with friends and I ask "so, what have you had going on lately?", none answer with their church mission trips, orhow they've been reading their bible, orhow they've been studying for the Sunday school class they teach?





I'd honestly RATHER those kinds of answers face to face because then I could probably tell whether they were genuine or not.





(And please don't get me wrong...I don't have one problem with church or God. And I'm not wanting any kind of debate on God or church. I just wish the answers sounded a bit more genuine and not thought out as to what might sound best.)
 
  Reply With Quote
HarleyGrrl is offline HarleyGrrl Post #10  October 12,2008, 4:34pm
HarleyGrrl's Avatar

A day without sunshine is like...well, night.

Quick Study

Joined: Aug 2008

Texas

Posts: 144

See profile



OBeth,291369 wrote :


HAVE YOU NOTICED under topic "Success Stories" there are only 20 posts with 491 views vs.. topic "Dating" which has 2908 topics and 109029 views? Pretty clear indication that most and I mean the vast majority of us are going to get nothing out of EH except puzzlement, frustration and dissappointment.


Men and women - we have analyzed, categorized and stereotyped ourselves to death.


I don't think there is a snowballs chance in hell I'm going to meet any man - not even one that is shorter than me, doesn't know how to read (or even spell the name of his "profession").is fat and bald, earns below the poverty line,snorts, farts, has bad table manners, drives a Monster truckthat he modified himself 20 years ago and still thinks that he's God's gift to women and that I owe him something after finally making a dinner date at McDonald'sand paying for my own Big Macto find out that he's absolutely nothing like the photo nor profile that he has put out their to lure me in.


Jaded? You bet. Disgusted? Absolutely. Ashamed of my attitude? Not tonight......


I've noticed it, but not to that extent. Now you've got me heading over there to look!!





Sorry...but your post tickled me! I guess probably because you had the nerve to actuall spout it out and not apologize for it.





I get to feeling that way, too at times. But then I just have to remember thateH paid big money to those marketing folks, and their commercials and ads work. I'm trying to keep a positive attitude, but I'm not betting my 401 on it.





H*ll...I ain't even betting my lunch money on it.
 
  Reply With Quote
Reply
  • Page 1 of 3
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3


Topic Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new topics
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are Off

Looking for a Great Relationship?

Get started now. Fill out this form and take the questionnaire to receive your matches.

First Name:

I'm a:
seeking

Postal Code:

Country:

Email:

Confirm Email:

Password:


How did you hear about us?


Latest on our Dating Advice Discussion Boards

“ ...90%????? I'd say it's more like 60 to 70 percent of women who say they offer to pay on the first and subsequent dates, and/or have no problem with going dutch. I'm in the pool of women who ... ” –  legend29

Join the “who pays?” discussion

“I think you were there when he was hurting, and she was there when he wanted fun. He chose fun as a long term partner. That's understandable. The posters who've said you might be a reminder of the ... ” –  lynntlb78

Join the “Reuniting with EX” discussion

“ I know exactly where you are coming from. I went in thinking "man, it is just an email. Fire off a response, yeah or nay. What is the big deal?" but the truth is a little more complicated. Plus, I ... ” –  Freezepop

Join the “Guided Communication VS Email” discussion

“ I believe you and I got confused for a second. I didn't hit the Police officer. I hit the lady in front of me and then someone reported the accident and he came to check it out. That's how I met ... ” –  LadyVee

Join the “Confusing Man (LONG STORY)” discussion

“My bf just gave me advice about an adult child. I was in shock. He's never done that before. I didn't think he cared at all. The advice was really good too. It was supportive and I could see ... ” –  harnomygirl

Join the “Off -Topic” discussion



All times are GMT -8. The time now is 4:46pm.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2012, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.0