A Matter of Faith

by eHarmony Staff


A Matter of Faith

Let’s suppose you are dating someone new, and the two of you are delightfully well-matched in many respects. You share several hobbies. You root for the same football team. You enjoy similar foods, even the obscure ethnic dishes you thought no one else in the western world liked. There are no red flags in your mutual taste in music, movies, fashion, or how you spend your free time. Everything looks positive.

Except for one thing: You and your partner subscribe to different spiritual beliefs. But that’s okay, right? So long as you respect one another’s views, what’s the big deal?

The truth is, there isn’t a one-size-fits-all answer to that question. A lot depends on individual personalities and particular religious traditions. But for many of us, matters of spirituality and religion are extremely important. They help define who we are and how we’ll live our lives.

Advertisement

The truth is, spiritual dissimilarity in a relationship may not be an automatic “deal breaker,” but neither is it insignificant. Let’s look at three steps that will help you think through your own circumstances:

Be realistic.
For lots of people, religious faith is about far more than periodically attending services or observing sacred holidays throughout the year. Those are only the most visible effects of spiritual dedication in a person’s life. In fact, for many people religious beliefs shape what they value, the way they relate to others, and how they respond to life’s challenges.

What people believe in can’t help but influence their goals—and limit what they are willing to do to reach them. In other words, spirituality is a signpost at all the most important crossroads in life. For instance, if you plan to start a family, consider that the arrival of children prompts a whole host of faith-based decisions: the traditions you will pass down, the rituals you will observe, the values you will instill.

It is wise to have your eyes wide open to the implications of facing all of life’s ups and downs with a partner who may not share your deepest beliefs.

Know your limits.
There isn’t a single set of criteria for what it takes to be “spiritually compatible.” For some it is enough to know their partner believes in a higher power. Others may feel it is necessary to be with someone from the same faith, or even within the same denomination or sect. It will help to know clearly where you stand on the subject, as you size up the potential of your present relationship. Ask yourself: To what degree must my partner and I share similar beliefs? How much room for differences I am comfortable with?

Give yourself the freedom to use your veto power.
If you honestly conclude that the spiritual distance between you and your partner is too great to overcome, then say so now. It’s possible that your beliefs could grow closer over time—but don’t count on it. Keeping your faith sometimes means having the courage to say no to a compromise you can’t stand behind in the long run.

The purpose of all faith is to live with wisdom, honesty, and grace. Apply those qualities to your search for a lasting relationship—and have the courage to honor your deeply held convictions.

Looking for a Great Relationship?

Get started now. Fill out this form and take the questionnaire to receive your matches.

First Name:

I'm a:
seeking

Postal Code:

Country:

Email:

Confirm Email:

Password:


How did you hear about us?



50 Comments View this thread in our community


myrtlebeachmale

September 27,2009 at 10:24 pm

brneyedangel: While I have a tremendous amount of respect for people of differing beliefs and religions, when it comes to spending the rest of my life with a person, we must be of the same faith. In my life, faith plays a huge role when it comes to how I make decisions, how I choose to live, and the person I have become and CHOOSE to be. To commit my life to someone who doesn't understand and share that with me just wouldn't work. In the past, I've seen how this differing opinion hasn't worked, and quite honestly, monetary issues and issues of raising children, among many others, are tied tightly to my basic beliefs, morals, and standards, all of which are strongly rooted in my faith. For me, at least, this is the way it must be.

I totally agree. Well said

duffbeer

September 27,2009 at 11:21 am

David916: Yes, religions have been and are the source of many conflicts, but they also form the bases of communities and powers for good.

You don't need religion to do good things. Non- religious people are just as caring and charitable as religious people.

Uncle Apple

September 24,2009 at 10:12 pm

Good advice. But what it comes down to, depends on the couple. For example, if I had a gf whose of a different religion, it would be fine with me if she attends her church, and i attend mine. If she wants me to attend hers, occassionally, it would be selfish to say no. it might even kill the relationship and the friendship, too. But if she was to insist that I switch to her religion, then I'd say adios, Senorita! or try to convert her, if converting has to be done. Or if I wanted  to marry her, and her family's conditions/stipulations included switching to their religion, that would end it for me. "Adios! It's been intersting knowing you." . Do you understand what I'm saying? I don't know if I can explain it, any differently.

empress_c

August 27,2009 at 05:26 pm

I guess it's up to me, since no one else has, to bring up Swedenborg.

While I may not have the wrath of God heaping coals of fire on my head immediately, the wrath of quite a few posters might directed to me. I am not saying anyone is "wrong" so please extend the same courtesy to me.

According to Swedenborg, everyone is allowed into heaven. That includes atheists. People are also allowed to choose hell if they prefer. It's up to the individual. Swedenborg (1688 - 1772) was exceptionally well educated, and a not very large religion was founded upon his beliefs after he "entered the spiritual world." If anyone wants more details, he wrote dozens of books, originally all in Latin, but long available in English. It is slow going if you want to try to read most of the encyclopedia style, many-paged books. "Heaven and Hell" is one of the few easier to read, an fine introduction, or an answer to your questions if you want to know what the hell (heaven?) I'm talking about. It's also a shorter book.

That said, I do have my (I hope) future matches' religious preferences limited to a list of some liberal Christian denominations. I don't consider bickering of what we do and don't believe to be enjoyable recreation. I don't want to give up or take up some practices because of conflicting rules. This attitude applies to many areas, of which religion is only one, for compatible marriage.

Now, remember, I haven't trashed any of your opinions. Yes, I have read and studied my bible. Yes, I have observed the negative aspects of religion (due to flawed humans). I did attempt to quit believing, but there are too many coincidences. So, I have come to my own conclusions, and I am at peace. I sincerely wish all of you are, or will be, at peace also.

David916

August 27,2009 at 03:20 pm

JDavid: .

You seem to have failed to include (or consider) the significant number of people who are "neither spiritual nor religious".

Non-religious people form their core values and morals from sources OTHER than religion.

Also, people who worship supernatural beings other than the supernatural biblical "god" of Christianity (real or imaginary) form their core values from a different (and no less valid) source.

Many from competing religions and from non-religion take their values VERY seriously.

Unfortunately, some who worship one of the thousands of available "gods" assume that anyone who does not share their beliefs is WRONG and will suffer in an "afterlife". They often denigrate the values, ethics, and morals of others as being inferior to their own.


Do you honestly not realize how condescending and hypocritical you sound in your posts? Your posts have continually denigrated religious people of all stripes.

Furthermore, by your logic concerning the alleged divisiveness of religions, no one should have any differing beliefs or opinions or preferences or group associations because those cause divisions and all divisions are bad. (So, maybe that could be a bit of an extreme extrapolation, but still...) People take comfort in groups of like-minded members. Yes, religions have been and are the source of many conflicts, but they also form the bases of communities and powers for good.

CreolePrincess

August 13,2009 at 05:30 pm

Personally, I'm very liberal when it comes to religion/spiritual beliefs. As long as my partner isn't putting down what I believe or trying to convert me to believe something else, I'm pretty much okay. However, I do have a preference that my partner hold similar beliefs. It seems that it would make the relationship a lot easier in the long haul.

Bob_dB

August 13,2009 at 11:46 am

JDavid: .

Unfortunately, some who worship one of the thousands of available "gods" assume that anyone who does not share their beliefs is WRONG and will suffer in an "afterlife". They often denigrate the values, ethics, and morals of others as being inferior to their own.


LOL - on the nosey: and isn't it funny how atheists never see themselves exactly like this?

CastleLady

August 12,2009 at 04:21 am

I was raised in one of the less fervent and more tolerant Christian denominations, and still tend to hold those general basic beliefs. However, life has exposed me to diverse belief systems, some of which I find very intriging, and I've found that specific religious denomination often has a lot less to do with compatibility than basic values. In fact, it may have nothing to do with it at all unless one person/partner makes it an issue.

Many people who claim to embrace a particular faith are not, in my opinion, the best examples of the traits that faith is meant to embody, and I've found that many basically non-religious people actually have stronger morals and ethics that many who claim to be religious. Values and ethics carry far more weight for me than flavor of dogma.

I value tolerance and diversity, so, while my profile reads: Christian, when I am matched (as seems to occur all too frequently) with someone who clearly is a Bible-thumper I close the match immediately. I have no interest in being matched with anyone whose scope is that narrow, nor do I wish to spend my time being preached to. As a result, I've considered changing my profile to read "Spiritual but not Religious", hoping that this might limit the number of matches for whom religion, or lack of it, is listed as one of the things about which they are most passionate.

Just introduce me to a funny, intelligent, tolerant man with good conversational skils and strong ethical values, and I really won't care much what specific creed he does or does not embrace.

JDavid

August 7,2009 at 03:05 pm

.

4408: Spiritual beliefs are core to who you are (unless you don't take them seriously)...I would NEVER date anyone who did not share my religious beliefs. The whole unequally yoked thing the Bible refers to....for me no compromise.

You seem to have failed to include (or consider) the significant number of people who are "neither spiritual nor religious".

Non-religious people form their core values and morals from sources OTHER than religion.

Also, people who worship supernatural beings other than the supernatural biblical "god" of Christianity (real or imaginary) form their core values from a different (and no less valid) source.

Many from competing religions and from non-religion take their values VERY seriously.

Unfortunately, some who worship one of the thousands of available "gods" assume that anyone who does not share their beliefs is WRONG and will suffer in an "afterlife". They often denigrate the values, ethics, and morals of others as being inferior to their own.

howa4x

August 7,2009 at 02:30 pm

It only works when you share similar core values, and similar truths about he universe. I was married for 20 yrs to a woman of a different faith, and when we split it wasn't  because of a blief that Jesus was the son of God or Moses did miraculos things. We both attended significant religious services of the others, and shared family get togethers, with the extneded on both sides. The kids loved it because they got double of everythng. We brought the kids up to see the oneness of it all and not the narrowness of one religion or another, and to respect people no matter what they believed or the color of their skin. All the kids turned out great, they all have a good sense of humor. We taught them how to think for themselves rather than only see the world through the eyes of one religion or another. All the war in the world is due to religion and most all preach hatred of other religions and sanction mass murder. so why would I want to be with somone who was so narrow minded anyway. the Hubble telescope has shown the vastness of the universe and has rendered religions petty.


Post new comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
More information about formatting options

By posting a comment, I agree to the Community Standards.
Need help with eHarmony.com?

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
3 + 2 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.